Beyond SDI: SDI+, Volume-Based SDI, MFI-0.45 and Why ASTM D8002 Was Withdrawn

SDI has been the standard RO feed-water test for decades, and its weaknesses are well documented. Several alternatives have been proposed. This guide sets out what each one fixes.
The known limits of SDI
A 2013 review by Alhadidi and co-workers lists them:
no correction for temperature;
no correction for differences in filter resistance;
no linear relationship with the concentration of particles;
variations in the 0.45 µm test filters themselves.
SDI+
The same authors built a model linking SDI to the modified fouling index, assuming cake filtration, and extended it to other fouling mechanisms. With it, a measured SDI can be normalised for pressure, temperature and filter resistance, giving SDI+. They validated the approach in the laboratory and at a seawater desalination plant. SDI+ keeps the familiar SDI test and adds a correction.
Volume-based SDI (SDIv)
The review also proposes comparing the initial flow rate with the flow rate after a fixed volume has passed, rather than after a fixed time. Their experiments showed this index did not depend on filter resistance.
MFI-0.45 and ASTM D8002
The modified fouling index measures how filtration resistance builds up per volume filtered, and it is linear with particle concentration under cake filtration. ASTM published D8002 as a test method for MFI-0.45, describing it as an alternative to SDI that addresses SDI's non-linearity, lack of temperature correction and dependence on test time. ASTM lists D8002 as withdrawn in 2024. MFI remains widely used in research and by plants that need a more quantitative number, but there is now no active ASTM method for it, so the procedure and filter must be agreed between the parties.
Which to use
For warranties, contracts and comparison with design guidelines: SDI to ASTM D4189, run carefully.
For trending, troubleshooting and difficult waters: MFI alongside SDI. The FILTON 4950 Pro runs MFI automatically; see MFI or SDI?.
To compare SDI across sites or seasons: log temperature, pressure and filter lot so results can be normalised later.
Write to mail@techincresearch.com or call +1 (289) 622-1032.
Equipment specifications are typical and may change. SDI results depend on the water, the filters, how the equipment is used and operation in line with the operation manual.
Sources
Desalination and Water Treatment 51 (2013) 1104–1113, Alhadidi et al., Limitations, improvements and alternatives of the silt density index.
ASTM International, ASTM D8002-15e1 Standard Test Method for Modified Fouling Index (MFI-0.45) of Water (withdrawn 2024).
ASTM International, ASTM D4189-23 Standard Test Method for Silt Density Index (SDI) of Water.





Comments