MFI or SDI? Measuring the Fouling Potential of Difficult RO Feeds with the FILTON 4950 Pro

The silt density index (SDI) is the test every RO plant knows. It is simple, it is written into membrane warranties, and for a well-pretreated feed it answers the question that matters: is this water acceptable? On difficult feeds, such as warm seawater, surface water after a storm or treated wastewater for reuse, operators often need a sharper answer: how much particulate fouling should they expect, and is it getting better or worse? That is where the modified fouling index, MFI-0.45, earns its place. The FILTON 4950 Pro measures it automatically, on the feed line, day and night.
Where SDI falls short
SDI compares the time to collect a fixed volume through a 0.45 µm filter at the start of a test with the time after 5, 10 or 15 minutes. It is a useful pass-or-fail number, but:
It is not proportional to the particulate load. Doubling the particles in the water does not double the SDI, so two SDI results cannot be compared as amounts.
It shifts with test conditions. Published work shows that SDI depends on pressure, water temperature and the resistance of the filter membrane itself, which helps explain why field results can be erratic.
What MFI-0.45 measures
MFI-0.45 uses the same kind of test: feed water through a 0.45 µm membrane filter at constant pressure. The difference is in what is recorded and how it is used. The filtered volume is logged against time for the whole test. Once a cake of particles forms on the filter, the plot of time/volume against volume becomes a straight line, and the slope of that line is the MFI, in s/L². Because it is based on cake filtration, MFI rises in step with the particulate load, and it is corrected for temperature and pressure, so results from different days and seasons can be compared.
ASTM published a test method for MFI-0.45 in 2015 (D8002) and withdrew it in 2024. The FILTON therefore runs its filtration at the conditions of ASTM D4189, the SDI standard: a 0.45 µm, 47 mm membrane at 2.07 bar (30 psi), and calculates MFI-0.45 from the full volume–time record.
How the FILTON 4950 Pro works
The FILTON 4950 Pro is built on the same platform as our Silton 4950 Pro automatic SDI analyser:
A side stream from the RO feed enters the cabinet. The built-in booster pump and regulator hold 2.07 bar at the filter, whatever the line pressure.
The drive advances a fresh section of 0.45 µm filter from a roll and the filter head clamps it.
The analyser logs the filtered volume against time, fits the straight-line part of the curve and reports MFI-0.45.
The result is logged, shown on the 7-inch touch screen and sent to the plant on 4–20 mA and RS-485 Modbus RTU. Alarm contacts flag an MFI over limit, an RO membrane bypass or a pump shut-off.
The used filter is wound on and the next test starts on schedule, with no operator at the instrument.
When to choose MFI
Feeds with a high or changing fouling potential: open seawater intakes, surface water, wastewater reuse.
Pretreatment trials, where you need to compare media filters, UF or coagulant doses by how much they reduce the fouling load.
Plants that want to estimate how fast feed pressure will climb, not just whether the feed passes.
For well-pretreated feeds where an SDI limit is all that is needed, the Silton SDI analysers remain the simpler choice. For operator-run MFI testing, see the FILTON 4750. The whole range is on SDI Measurement Instruments.
What to send us
For a quotation, tell us the water source and pretreatment, the line pressure at the sample point, how often you want a test, your power supply and how results should reach your control system. Write to mail@techincresearch.com or call +1 (289) 622-1032.
Specifications are typical and may change. Results depend on the feed water, how the instrument is used and operation in line with the operation manual.
Sources
ASTM International, ASTM D8002-15e1 Standard Test Method for Modified Fouling Index (MFI-0.45) of Water (withdrawn 2024).
Alhadidi A., Kemperman A.J.B., Blankert B., Schippers J.C., Wessling M., van der Meer W.G.J., Silt Density Index and Modified Fouling Index relation, and effect of pressure, temperature and membrane resistance, Desalination 273 (2011) 48–56.
ASTM International, ASTM D4189-23 Standard Test Method for Silt Density Index (SDI) of Water.





Comments