top of page

When SDI15 Is Not Valid: The 75% Plugging Limit, SDI5 and SDI10 Explained

Writer: Tech Inc
Tech Inc
2 days ago
2 min read

SDI looks like a simple number, but it has a built-in ceiling, and many reported values ignore it. Understanding the plugging limit avoids reporting results that the method does not support.

The arithmetic

  • %P = (1 − ti/tf) × 100

  • SDIT = %P / T

Because %P cannot exceed 100, SDI15 cannot exceed 100/15 = 6.67, however dirty the water.

The 75% limit

The method expects plugging at the end of the interval to stay at or below 75%. Above that, the filter is so blocked that the result no longer tracks the water quality well. At 75% plugging over 15 minutes, SDI15 = 75/15 = 5.0. So a reported SDI15 above 5 means the test ran past the limit and should be repeated with a shorter interval.

Worked example (illustrative numbers)

  • ti = 28 s for the first 500 mL.

  • After 15 minutes, tf = 140 s.

  • %P = (1 − 28/140) × 100 = 80%. Above 75%, so SDI15 is not valid.

Repeat with a fresh filter and T = 5 minutes:

  • ti = 28 s, tf at 5 minutes = 45 s.

  • %P = (1 − 28/45) × 100 = 37.8%, within the limit.

  • SDI5 = 37.8 / 5 = 7.6.

SDI5 is not SDI15

Plugging does not grow in a straight line with time, so an SDI5 of 4 is not the same water quality as an SDI15 of 4. Always report the interval with the number, and compare like with like.

What a high SDI tells you

If a water cannot pass a 15-minute test, the pretreatment is not doing its job for RO. Use SDI5 or SDI10 to track improvement while the pretreatment is fixed, then return to SDI15.

Equipment

The Siltometer 500 Max is built for seawater and difficult feeds. The Silton 4950 Pro calculates both SDI and the plugging factor for every test and logs them, so a result past the limit is easy to spot. For waters that plug too fast for SDI at all, see MFI or SDI?.

Write to mail@techincresearch.com or call +1 (289) 622-1032.

Equipment specifications are typical and may change. SDI results depend on the water, the filters, how the equipment is used and operation in line with the operation manual.

Sources

Comments


bottom of page